 Impossible to Obtain Red Wedding Cake Hat | 4,880 | 1,083 | — | — | — | 136 | 502 | 89% |
 Improved Solar System | 2,999 | 313 | — | — | — | 84 | 346 | 86% |
 Improvised Straw Hat | 400 | 379 | — | — | — | 111 | 293 | 81% |
 In Her Majesty's Service | 8,000 | 2,524 | — | — | — | 193 | 472 | 76% |
 Inaugural Top Hat | 100,000 | 3,066 | — | — | — | 109 | 392 | 91% |
 Incinerator 6000 | 4,500 | 428 | — | — | — | 76 | 311 | 83% |
 Incredibles 2 Cap | 540 | 808 | — | — | — | 119 | 987 | 97% |
 Incredibles 2 Sunglasses | 1,500 | 160 | — | — | — | 131 | 577 | 94% |
 Independence Day Cap | 20,000 | 107 | — | — | — | 77 | 351 | 91% |
 Independence Day Fireworks 2015 | 2,850 | 3,327 | — | — | — | 135 | 550 | 88% |
 Independence Top Hat | 1,400 | 855 | — | — | — | 56 | 336 | 93% |
 Indigo Inferno Shades | 500 | 126 | — | — | — | 152 | 681 | 91% |
 Indomitus Leo: A Walmart Exclusive Item | 7,500 | 278 | — | — | — | 197 | 268 | 38% |
 Industrial Revolutionary | 600 | 425 | — | — | — | 199 | 759 | 91% |
 Ineffective Rockstar Disguise | 1,200 | 1,417 | — | — | — | 73 | 210 | 84% |
 Dark Tidings | 4,000 | 3,165 | — | — | — | 65 | 212 | 77% |
 Inferno Guardian Helm | 999,999,999 | 16,849 | — | — | — | 30 | 120 | 85% |
 Infinity Gauntlet Egg | 1,500 | 505 | — | — | — | 260 | 7,820 | 98% |
 Inflatable Cowboy Hat | 1,000 | 236 | — | — | — | 105 | 290 | 79% |
 Inflatable Sword | 6,999 | 3,460 | — | — | — | 90 | 183 | 71% |
 Inflatable Top Hat | 1,500 | 51 | — | — | — | 57 | 179 | 88% |
 Infrared Scout | 1,000 | 360 | — | — | — | 139 | 288 | 70% |
 Inkwell Egg | 998 | 506 | — | — | — | 873 | 2,531 | 82% |
 Inky the Cyclops | 5,000 | 2,804 | — | — | — | 100 | 525 | 86% |
 Insanely Valuable Crystal Egg | 7,777 | 2,774 | — | — | — | 170 | 1,748 | 95% |
 InsectZoids: Dr. Mantis_Pinchers | 677 | 201 | — | — | — | 164 | 636 | 88% |
 DarkAge Ninja Bow | 500,000 | 17,499 | — | — | — | 28 | 98 | 88% |
 Insectaur Helmet | 800 | 118 | — | — | — | 163 | 536 | 87% |
 Insectibot | 150,000 | 31,819 | — | — | — | 27 | 62 | 68% |
 Inspector Catpunk | 4,000 | 1,416 | — | — | — | 49 | 208 | 88% |
 Installation Wizard | 9,999 | 219 | — | — | — | 77 | 247 | 87% |
 Instamatic Tent | 390 | 311 | — | — | — | 127 | 341 | 81% |
 Instant Campfire | 9,000 | 4,302 | — | — | — | 49 | 114 | 74% |
 Instant Treehouse | 10,000 | 1,376 | — | — | — | 101 | 220 | 70% |
 Intergalactic Bunny | 5,000 | 1,681 | — | — | — | 226 | 492 | 70% |
 Intergalactic Officer | 15,000 | 7,721 | — | — | — | 49 | 225 | 90% |
 Intergalactic Pilot | 15,000 | 74 | — | — | — | 64 | 192 | 84% |
 Intern Racing Chair 2014 | 25,000 | 16,640 | — | — | — | 40 | 250 | 67% |
 International Fedora - Argentina | 299 | 340 | — | — | — | 616 | 8,351 | 94% |
 International Fedora - Australia | 405 | 660 | — | — | — | 709 | 9,048 | 95% |
 International Fedora - Brazil | 200 | 204 | — | — | — | 645 | 5,812 | 93% |
 International Fedora - China | 10,000 | 4,577 | — | — | — | 453 | 8,293 | 97% |
 International Fedora - Colombia | 4,334 | 830 | — | — | — | 473 | 8,307 | 97% |
 International Fedora - Indonesia | 300 | 221 | — | — | — | 471 | 5,201 | 95% |
 International Fedora - Mexico | 590 | 611 | — | — | — | 550 | 8,177 | 96% |
 International Fedora - Netherlands | 1,000 | 492 | — | — | — | 300 | 7,117 | 98% |
 International Fedora - Philippines | 1,210 | 628 | — | — | — | 379 | 5,331 | 96% |
 International Fedora - Poland | 15,000 | 3,954 | — | — | — | 301 | 5,985 | 97% |
 International Fedora - South Korea | 900 | 533 | — | — | — | 341 | 5,760 | 97% |
 Kaiser Helm | 3,333 | 2,271 | — | — | — | 89 | 498 | 86% |